| FY 2007-08 STATE BUDGET
PRESCRIPTION FOR PENNSYLVANIA
The Governor’s Fiscal Year 2007-08 budget proposal
for the Insurance Department is dominated by his comprehensive health
care reform proposal Prescription for Pennsylvania, or Rx for PA.
The Governor’s Rx for PA proposal comes at a time when states
across the nation are beginning to enact bolder and bolder reform
initiatives to tackle the problems of burgeoning health care costs
and growing uninsured populations. Governor Rendell’s plan
is in many ways the most ambitious and all-encompassing of any that
have been proposed or enacted.
The Rx for PA will cost a total of $150.9 million in state funds
in FY2007-08 with an addition $104.4 million in leveraged federal
matching funds, a portion of these funds will be raised through
an increase in the Cigarette Tax, and a new tax on other tobacco
products which will raise a combined $77.5 million. Funds for the
Rx for PA plan will be disbursed through various state agencies
including the Departments of Insurance, Health, Education, Labor
and Industry, and Public Welfare, the Health Care Cost Containment
Council, and the Office of Health Care Reform. The majority of the
funding issues for the Rx for PA, however, revolve around the Governor’s
Cover All Pennsylvanians initiative.
Cover All Pennsylvanians
At the heart of the Governor’s plan is the Cover All Pennsylvanians
initiative which will offer an affordable basic health insurance
plan for small businesses and the uninsured.
A recent study conducted by the Pennsylvania Insurance Department
found that there are approximately 767,000 Pennsylvanians who do
not have health insurance. The survey also found that most of these
767,000 people are employed, and that most of them do not have health
insurance because of the prohibitively high costs for both small
businesses and individuals. Finally, of the 767,000 uninsured people
in Pennsylvania, almost 581,000 earn less than 300% of the Federal
Poverty Level.
Cover All Pennsylvanians will be an insurance program that is supported
by the state and offered through private insurance companies. Employers
can participate in the program if they have not offered health insurance
to their employees for the past six months, they have 50 or fewer
employees, and on average these employees earn less than the state
average wage.
Additionally, all uninsured individuals will be eligible to purchase
insurance through the program. Those earning less than 300% of the
Federal Poverty Level ($62,000 for a family of four) will receive
help from the state in paying part of their premiums.
The health care premium and administrative costs of the CAP program
in fiscal year 2007-08 are expected to be approximately $235 million,
of that amount $104 million will be provided by the federal government.
This figure is based upon an expectation to enroll 153,600 adults
in the Cover All Pennsylvanians program in FY2007-08. Enrollment
is expected to increase to 431,300 by FY2011-12 at which time the
cost of the program will be significantly larger and dependant upon
future health care costs and the mix of people taking part in the
program.
The Governor plans to fund the program in FY07-08 from a variety
of sources: existing money from the tobacco settlement agreement
totaling $31.3 million; existing money from the Community Health
Reinvestment Agreement totaling $52.2 million; Federal matching
funds totaling $104 million; and $60.4 million from a new Fair Share
Assessment tax.
The Fair Share Assessment will be a 3 percent tax levied on the
payrolls of businesses that do not offer health insurance to their
employees. The Community Health Reinvestment money will be available
because the adultBasic program will be collapsed into the Cover
All Pennsylvanians plan.
In addition to Cover All Pennsylvanians, the Rx for PA has provisions
designed to address the three issues of Affordability, Access, and
Quality.
Rx for Affordability
• $268,000 to expand the Commonwealth’s premium rate
review authority to all insures providing coverage in the individual
and small employer market.
• Require hospitals to immediately screen and redirect patients
who go to emergency rooms but do not require emergency room care
to more appropriate places within the hospital.
• $120,000 to develop recommendations and criteria for the
review and approval of health care services and facility planning.
• $810,000 to develop standardized policies and reporting
and auditing procedures for non-profit hospitals required to meet
community benefit obligations.
• $510,000 to develop and enforce standardized hospital admission
criteria and fair billing and collection procedures for uninsured
and underinsured patients.
Rx for Access
• Eliminate the barriers in existing laws, regulations, and
insurance reimbursement policies that limit the ability of health
care providers- such as nurses, nurse practitioners, midwives, physician
assistants, pharmacists, and dental hygienists- to practice to the
fullest extent of their training.
• $5.4 million to increase access to primary health care in
underserved rural areas.
• Provide incentives to increase the number of care centers
that offer services in the evening and on weekends.
Rx for Quality
• $2.3 million to standardize identification and reporting
of hospital acquired infections and to provide training in infection-control
best practices.
• Commonwealth will lead a coalition of other health care
purchasers from the private sector to align provider payments with
their expectations for quality care and will introduce a pay-for-performance
program into state funded health care programs.
• $2.5 million to develop a chronic care information system
with the ultimate goal being the implementation of a nationally
recognized and proven chronic care model.
• $719,000 to promote health literacy by enhancing the delivery
of health-promotion and risk-reduction messages.
• $1 million to reduce health disparities by increasing the
number of health professionals equipped to address the needs of
racial and ethnic minorities.
Overall Wellness Initiatives
• Ban smoking in all Pennsylvania workplaces, restaurants,
and bars.
• $6.5 million to increase the number of school breakfasts
served and to provide incentives for schools that adopt best-practice
nutritional guidelines.
• $30,000 for elementary school teachers to integrate healthy
living concepts into lesson plans.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WELFARE
The Commonwealth’s General Fund total expenditures are projected
to grow by $948 million or 3.6%, while DPW’s General Fund
spending will grow by $367 million or 3.9%, which is in line with
the Commonwealth’s overall budget growth.
Of the $212 million in supplemental appropriations requested by
the Governor, $201 million or 95%, are in the Department of Public
Welfare. The largest supplemental requests are for Medical Assistance.
Despite constrained general fund spending, the Department’s
budget still contains expansion in program spending and does not
include any client or service reductions in the MA service program.
Medical Assistance
The most significant issues in the department’s budget relates
to Medical Assistance. This is part of a NATIONAL TREND. Caseloads
are increasing. Pennsylvania has the 3rd highest elderly population
and the fastest growing number of persons over 85. While the elderly
and disabled are only 34% of the total Medical Assistance population,
they account for 65% of the Medical Assistance dollars.
The current demographics for the Medical Assistance system
are as follows:
ITEM |
% of Caseload |
% of Dollars |
| Disabled |
20% |
33% |
| Elderly |
14% |
32% |
| Children & Families |
61% |
27% |
| Adults without children |
5% |
8% |
“Big 5” Medical Assistance Appropriations:
ITEM |
FY 06/07 |
FY 07/08 |
Difference |
| Outpatient |
$ 677,455 |
$1,008,562 |
$331,107 |
| Inpatient |
$ 489,472 |
$ 459,391 |
($30,081) |
| Capitation |
$2,724,839 |
$2,405,083 |
($319,756) |
| LTC (Long Term Care) |
$ 717,154 |
$ 799,113 |
$81,959 |
| Medicare Part D |
$ 338,500 |
$ 325,029 |
$(13,471) |
Total |
$4,947,420 |
$4,997,178 |
$49,758 |
Medical Assistance Cost Containment Initiatives
The Administration is proposing to support the 2007/08 Medical Assistance
program through a number of Cost Containment initiatives:
1) Redirect Voluntary Managed Care: Clients will be moved from the
Voluntary Managed Care program to fee-for-service system. $65 million
savings
2) MCO Pharmacy Carveout: Consolidate Medical Assistance pharmacy
services in the Fee-for-Service system. $45 million savings ($94
million savings when fully implemented)
3) Healthy Women Waiver: Additional federal revenue estimated at
$24.5 million will provide preventative health services for additional
women
4) Behavioral Health Service Expansion: Expand the availability
of behavioral health services through the Managed Care program.
$25 million savings
5) Change Managed Care Contracts: $315 million savings when changes
are made to MCO contract payment terms, including performance incentives
6) Nursing Home Resident Assessment Schedule: Change resident assessment
from monthly to quarterly $30 million savings
7) Reduce Hospital Payments: $33 million savings due to Prescription
for PA initiative Dual Eligible Drug Costs
The Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Program took
effect in January 2006. The new program moved persons who are dually
eligible for Medicaid and Medicare into a new Medicare Part D prescription
program. In order to fund the prescription drug costs of these dual
eligibles, the Federal Government is requiring States to pay a portion
of those costs. This is referred to as the “clawback”
provision of the Medicare Part D program. The Administration separates
these costs from the existing MA Outpatient appropriation. For FY
2007/2008, the Commonwealth’s clawback costs are $325 million,
a savings of $13 million over current year payments.
Medical Assistance Rates
The Governor proposes the following rate increases for Medical Assistance
providers:
- Managed Care Organizations: 3% with the opportunity to earn
an additional 2.5% increase based on performance
- Nursing Homes: 2%
- Hospitals: 2%
Reforming the Long Term Care System
In order to meet the challenge of the Commonwealth’s growing
elderly population, the Governor is proposing to use over $17 million
in state funds to expand long-term living options and the overall
long-term living system.
Beginning with home and community based service, the Governor is
proposing to use $12.7 million to serve an additional 2,200 individuals
over the age of 60 and an additional 1,000 individuals with disabilities
under the age of 60 in the Medicaid waiver program.
The Nursing Home Transition program will receive $3.8 million to
build up long term counseling and transition support services for
individuals who are able to be served safely in a home and community
based setting.
In order to educate the public on this initiative, $1.5 million
will be used for an outreach campaign to help Pennsylvanians make
informed decisions. To help balance of the continuum services, the
Governor is proposing $3.7 million for the development of domiciliary
care homes; $400,000 for additional housing; and $4.7 million to
encourage a balance between institutional care and home and community
based care over the next five years.
Income Maintenance
When compared to FY 06/07, the amount requested for Cash Grants
in FY 07/08 will be a significant decrease over the current year.
The $157 million decrease is due to moving the TANF and former TANF
recipients childcare program to a new line item, Childcare Assistance.
This will allow the Governor to monitor the quality and availability
of childcare for TANF and low income families.
Due to Federal changes to TANF reauthorization, the Commonwealth
was required by October 1, 2006 to have 50% of its TANF clientele
in some kind of federal approved work activity. In a recent DPW
briefing, Secretary Richman announced that Pennsylvania was just
shy of the 50% goal. States will not face a penalty for non compliance
until State FY 2009/10.
The appropriation for Supplemental Grants for the Aged, Blind and
Disabled will increase by $2.6 million, including $1.6 million to
offset additional caseload costs.
There is no provision for a state supplement for LIHEAP for 2007/08.
Mental Health and Mental Retardation
The Mental Health program will receive a significant increase of
30.1 million over current year funding. Part of the $30.1 million
is for a new initiative, Expanding Community Mental Health Services,
which will provide 200 individuals currently residina in state hospitals
an opportunity to live in a home and community based program. In
addition, 2,000 families of children with mental illness will receive
respite care services.
The Governor recommends a 3% cola for Mental Health Services.
The Mental Retardation program will receive substantial increases
under the Governor’s budget: $78.5 million or a 9.9% increase
for Community Mental Retardation Services and nearly $14.5 million
or a 13.7% increase for Early Intervention.
The Mental Retardation appropriation includes a $28.9 million initiative,
Expanding Community Mental Retardation services to provide home
and community based mental retardation services for 3,428 additional
individuals on the waiting list.
The Early Intervention appropriation includes $8.3 million to provide
early intervention services to an additional 1,529 children ages
birth to 3 years of age.
$1.9 million has been proposed to serve an additional 100 persons
with Autism in a home and community based care system.
Community MH/MR Programs and the Early Intervention program contain
funding for a 3% cost - of - living adjustment.
Services for Children
Child Welfare funding will increase from $881 million in 2006-07
to $948 million 2007-08. This includes $56.2 million to support
county needs-based budgets.
In 2007-08, the TANF Child Welfare Transition appropriation will
be reduced by $30 million from current year funding. The phase-out
of the funds is part of the initiative the Administration proposed
in the 2005-06 budget.
In addition, the Governor has proposed to strengthen the Early Education
and Care Initiative by providing a $19 million increase to Child
Care Services. These funds will provide additional subsidized child
care services to 400 low – income children and improve accountability
of early learning experiences through the Keystone Stars programs.
The Nurse Family Partnership program will receive an additional
$587,000 to provide services to 184 additional families.
In order to monitor the quality and availability of childcare for
TANF and former TANF families, the Governor has proposed a new line
item, Childcare Assistance. This new line item is composed of $157
million transferred from the Cash Grant appropriation and $52 million
in funding to strengthen the existing program, including funding
for a $10.8 million initiative to increase provider rates to ensure
access to child care.
Other Social Programs
The Governor’s budget provides substantial increases in General
Fund appropriations for Services to Persons with Disabilities and
Attendant Care, as well as Home and Community Based Services in
the Tobacco Fund.
• $2.9 million has been provided in the Persons with Disabilities
appropriation to provide services to an additional 405 persons.
• $3.7 million is recommended to provide Attendant Care to
an additional 595 individuals.
• Both the Persons with Disabilities and Attendant Care appropriations
contains funds for a 3% COLA.
In addition, Domestic Violence, Rape Crisis, Breast Cancer Screening,
Legal Services, and Homeless Assistance will receive a 3% COLA.
DEPARTMENT OF AGING
The Governor proposes funding all general fund line items, with
the exception of the Alzheimer’s Outreach program, from the
lottery fund. This would save the general fund in excess of $19.0
million.
Family Caregiver Support Program
The Family Caregiver Support Program appropriation contains a small
increase to provide for a 3 percent cost-of-living adjustment. This
program is also supported by $10 million in federal funds. The program
assists families who maintain frail relatives in their home. Working
through AAA’s, the program provides benefits counseling and,
depending on income, financial assistance including supplies, services
and home adaptations and devices. It is anticipated that 5,545 families
will receive these services in 2007-08.
Alzheimer’s Outreach Services
The Governor’s budget includes $250,000 for Alzheimer’s
Outreach Services. Federal Funds used for Memory Loss programs are
no longer available, however it is anticipated that Pennsylvania
will receive $350,000 in federal funds for an Alzheimer’s
Demonstration Grant program.
Pre-Admission Assessment
Funding for the Pre-Admission Assessment Program is increased by
34 percent for a total of $10.3 million in lottery funds, in the
Governor’s recommended budget. This increase reflects the
transfer of assessment activities from PENNCARE to maximize federal
earnings. This nursing home pre-admission screening program helps
older Pennsylvanians and their families determine the least restrictive
environment needed and assists them in securing and managing intensive
in-home services tailored to their needs. It is anticipated that
assessments and referrals to community services will increase in
2007-08. Referrals to nursing homes are expected to decrease.
PENNCARE
This budget proposal includes a $15.0 million increase in the lottery
funded PENNCARE appropriation to continue the current Attendant
Care Program and provide services to an additional 346 recipients.
Funds are also used for Older Adult Protective Services to investigate
suspected elder abuse reports. The increase would also be used to
provide a 3 percent cost of living adjustment for direct care workers
and to provide services as a result of nursing home transition activities.
In addition, the Governor is proposing an initiative – Reforming
the Long-Term Living System – aimed at reducing reliance on
institutional long-term care and promoting growth of high quality
home and community-based services. The PENNCARE appropriation includes
$4.8 million to fund this initiative.
Home and Community-Based Services – Tobacco Settlement Fund
A total of $21.3 million in Tobacco Settlement funding is included
in the Governor’s budget to provide home and community-based
services to older Pennsylvanians. This includes an increase of almost
$2.0 million to continue current home and community-based services
and expansion to additional recipients, as well as nursing home
transition activities. In addition, $4.6 million is proposed to
be used for the Governor’s Reforming the Long-Term Living
System initiative, to reduce reliance on institutional care. Federal
funds in the amount of $2.4 million are also provided for this initiative.
Reforming the Long-Term Living System
The Governor’s budget includes a total of $12.9 million in
lottery, tobacco and federal funds under the Department of Aging
to fund an initiative to reduce reliance on institutional long-term
care and promote growth of high quality home and community-based
services. An additional 2,200 individuals over the age of 60 will
be able to remain in their homes or a community-based setting rather
than moving to a nursing home.
Pennsylvania has the third oldest population of any state, and the
fastest growing segment of this population is over age 85. The demand
for services is expected to grow over the next several years until
the 85+ population stabilizes in 2011.
Providing services for the rapidly growing number of seniors, especially
those 85 and older, will present a major challenge for the commonwealth
in the coming years. The number of seniors using home and community-based
services has increased 70 percent since 2002-03. An additional 14
percent increase is projected in the current year.
The problem will come to a head in the near future, as 2006 was
the year that the first wave of baby boomers, many struggling to
care for elderly parents, joined the ranks of the 60-plus year olds.
By the year 2020, one in every four Pennsylvanians will be age 60
or older.
PACE and PACENET
The Pharmaceutical Assistance Program provides help to qualified
older Pennsylvanians who are 65 years of age and over and whose
cost of drugs is a burden to them. The program is financed by the
Lottery and Tobacco Settlement Fund revenue.
The commonwealth has expanded its PACE and PACENET programs to make
them compatible with and complementary to the new Medicare prescription
drug program. PACE Plus Medicare enables cardholders to take advantage
of the features of both PACE and the new Federal Medicare Part D
benefit by filling the gaps encountered by cardholders in Medicare
Part D including deductibles, the donut hole phase of no Medicare
coverage, and co-payment differentials between the Part D plan coverage
and the PACE and PACENET copayments. PACE Plus pays the Medicare
premiums for Part D coverage PACE cardholders, while PACENET cardholders
pay the Part D premium.
With a heavier reliance on lottery funds and a reduced use of tobacco
settlement funds, the Governor’s budget proposes funding for
2007-08 that will allow the average number of seniors covered by
PACE, PACENET or PACE Plus Medicare to rise to 357,725 which represents
an additional 32,000 seniors. This represents a 10 percent increase
over those receiving services in 2006-07 and a 60 percent increase
since 2002-03. The budget includes $276.4 million in state funds
to continue these programs.
CORRECTIONS
In the Governor’s proposed budget, state spending for the
Department of Corrections would reach nearly $1.6 billion, an increase
of $155.4 million or 11% over current year funding level.
Increases in the daily inmate population have required the Department
to request a $163 million increase for the State Correctional Institutions.
The increase is necessary to house an offender population that reached
nearly 44,365 inmates in December 2006. Currently, there are 4,313
inmates in excess of operational bed capacity. Inmate population
forecasts show an average increase of 1500 inmates per year over
the next five fiscal years. Of the $163 million, $11.7 million is
for The Community Corrections Centers, which will also see a capacity
increase and require additional housing unit needs.
The 2007/2008 cost per inmate is projected at $34,021, an increase
of $3,185 per day per inmate over current year funding level. The
increase in the inmate population is the biggest challenge facing
the Department and the Commonwealth. In order to begin to deal with
prison overcrowding, the Governor is reactivating SCI Pittsburgh,
with an initial capacity of 750 beds by July 2007. The cost to reopen
SCI Pittsburgh is $32.5 million.
The Governor has proposed two new initiatives to reduce prisoner
recidivism. The Vocational Education Improvement initiative will
receive $2.4 million to better equip offenders with vocational skills
to increase their chances at employment and lessen their chance
of recidivism. Another initiative, Reintegration Program, will receive
$792,000 to enhance inmate skills and treatment in order to improve
their chances of success outside of the prison environment.
As the inmate population continues to rise so do the medical care
expenses for the inmates. The Department has requested a $12.6 million
(6.6%) increase in the medical care appropriation for the continuation
of current medical services.
GENERAL FUND
2007-08 Fiscal Year
The Governor’s proposed general fund budget contains modest
expenditure growth of 3.6% or $27.27 billion for the 2007-08 fiscal
year. However, he anticipates revenue growth to be only 2.25% so
he proposing a tax increase of $921 million to balance the budget.
The tax increase revenue will primarily come from a 1% increase
in the sales tax. Each 1% of sales tax brings in over $1.4 billion
in revenue, the Governor’s plan, however, diverts $420 million
to Property Tax Relief Fund so only $826 million goes to the General
Fund. The remainder of the tax proposal will be detailed later in
this report.
2006-07 Fiscal Year (Current Year)
The Governor’s budget book shows two changes to the 2006-07
fiscal year. First the amount of requested supplemental appropriations
increases from $39.5 million expected in December in his mid-year
briefing to $211.6 million. These additional supplementals are entirely
for spending in the Public Welfare realm and will be listed elsewhere
in this report. The second change is there is $161.7 million more
revenue expected in this fiscal year. This revenue results from
a reduction of $95 million in the amount of money expected for tax
refunds and an expected revenue surplus of $66.7 million at the
end of the fiscal year.
TAX CHANGES 2007-08
In order to balance the budget the Governor is recommending $921
million in additional taxes and revenues. As the chart below shows
90% of the expected new revenue is from a 1% increase in the sales
tax.
Sales Tax The sales tax increase should raise about $1.424 billion
annually. The increase would be effective July 1, 2007. Since there
is a one month delay from the time the sales tax is collected by
the merchant and when it is sent to the Commonwealth the first year
will only contain 11 months of collections. The Governor’s
proposal transfers $420 million to the Property Tax Relief Fund,
which leaves $826 million for the General Fund. For all subsequent
years half of this sale tax increase or about $700 million will
go into the Property Tax Relief Fund.
Transfer from Oil Company Gross Profits Tax The Governor’s
transit plan creates a new tax that will be utilized to fund that
proposal. There is, however, a small impact on the General Fund:
If oil companies are going to be paying this new tax they will be
exempted from the CNI collected into the General Fund. This transfer
of $17 million simply makes the General Fund whole.
Cigarette Tax There is a10 cents a pack increase proposed for the
cigarette tax. That increase is expected to raise $49.7 million.
Other Tobacco Products A new tax is proposed on other tobacco products
such as snuff, pipe tobacco and cigars. These items are current
only taxed under the sales tax and not by an excise tax.
Abusive Tax Shelters The Governor continues his campaign against
abusive tax shelters used by corporations to avoid paying taxes
to Pennsylvania. This proposal is expected to raise $10 million
this year. There will be additional costs to the Department of Revenue
in order for them to raise this additional money.
Educational Improvement Tax Credit A small increaqe of $1.4 millihn
ip propmqdd bhr phir popular tax credit.
Fee Increases Within DEP Various fees that have not been adjusted
in some time are slated to be raised to bring in an additional $9.1
million. Fees such as inspection of dams are the fees to be raised
here.
* * *
|